Apple Intelligence vs. Third-Party AI Apps on Mac

Written by Sandy Writtenhouse

Apple officially launched Apple Intelligence for iOS, iPadOS, and macOS in 2025. So, with all that it can do, do Mac users still need third-party AI apps or is Apple’s AI enough? Here, we’ll explore where Mac’s system-side Apple Intelligence excels and where third-party AI apps remain stronger.

What is Apple Intelligence on Mac?

Apple Intelligence is a system intended to improve the experience on your Apple devices using artificial intelligence. You can use the built-in AI model for things like writing, image generation, and productivity. Plus, it’s integrated into apps like Mail, Notes, Safari, Messages, and Pages.

Some of its features include:

So, whether you want to summarize a lengthy email thread, remove background distractions from a photo, or find something you shared in a note or text, this free AI for Mac can help.

What makes Apple Intelligence stand out in the privacy category is its use of both on-device and Private Cloud Compute resources.

When you make a request, the task is analyzed to determine if it can be processed locally on your Mac. If it’s too complex, it’s handled securely using Private Cloud Compute. Only the information relevant to your request is processed through this service; no data is stored or available to Apple.

Best Third-Party Productivity AI Apps for Mac

When it comes to productivity, AI can be a fantastic tool that speeds up tasks of most any size. Even though Apple Intelligence is integrated into Apple’s native apps, you can take AI further with additional tools like creative content generators and smart email organizers.

Below are just a few of the best AI apps for Mac in the productivity genre.

Writing Apps

ChatGPT is an all-around good application for general content creation. You can get help writing articles, blog posts, emails, speeches, essays, presentations, and more. It’s ideal for individuals, lets you make edits such as text length or reading level, and offers translations to most any language.

ChatGPT is a versatile application for general content creationChatGPT is a versatile application for general content creation

Jasper is a great option for crafting marketing content including everything from blog and social media posts to email campaigns and product descriptions. It’s perfect for teams and provides a digital workspace, integrations and extensions, an app library, an image suite, and enterprise-grade security.

Jasper AI marketing content creation toolJasper AI marketing content creation tool

Note-Taking and Transcription Apps

Otter provides services for live transcriptions, meeting summaries, and automated action items. It integrates seamlessly with applications like Google Meet, Slack, Zoom, Notion, Microsoft Teams, and many more. For both individuals and teams, you can use AI templates, ask questions with AI chat, and receive useful insights from your meetings.

Otter AI meeting transcription and summary tool

Whisper Notes offers speech-to-text functionality for meeting notes and memos. It provides voice recording and transcription, import and export abilities, and multiple language support. The app works offline for audio captures anywhere, making it a good choice for college lectures, business seminars, and multilingual events.

Whisper Notes for speech-to-text meeting notes

Email Decluttering Apps

Clean Email fills the gap where Apple Intelligence and Mail leave off by allowing you to organize, clean, and unsubscribe using bulk actions and helpful automations. It’s a formidable mailbox management tool that doesn’t technically use AI, but behaves as such with its smart and robust feature set. This makes Clean Email a solid productivity enhancer to accompany your Mac’s AI features.

Organize mail on Mac with Clean EmailOrganize mail on Mac with Clean Email

💡 Note: Clean Email is safe to use, doesn’t sell your data, and is fully compliant with Gmail’s Privacy Policy. You can download the Clean Email app for Mac or try it as a web app.

Task Automation Apps

Notion is a superior automated task and workflow application offering a built-in Notion AI feature. With it, you can describe your desired workflow and have it created for you. You can also design a database, automate meeting notes, autofill data, perform research, and create detailed documents and reports. The app works well for both individuals and teams.

Notion for task and workflow automation with AI

Apple Intelligence vs Third-Party AI Assistants

AI assistants provide more than one service. They can help you perform various tasks, automate workflows, create content, research information, manage schedules, and much more, in both personal and professional settings.

Launched to the public in 2011, Apple offers Siri as its AI assistant for Mac as well as iPhone and iPad. With the release of Apple Intelligence, Siri is more powerful with “on-screen awareness” allowing it to act on information displayed on your screen. Additionally, you can make requests based on previous ones. Siri then harnesses the power of ChatGPT to perform more complex actions.

In the third-party realm, a couple of competing AI assistants are Microsoft Copilot and Google Gemini, but other comparable options include apps like Claude and Perplexity. One notable advantage to these tools is that they’re widely available. So, where you can only use Siri on Apple devices, you can use these third-party options on most any device.

✅ Where Apple excels: It has tight OS integration and offers offline options.

❌ Where Apple lacks: It has fewer advanced research features and provides less creative freedom.

Apple Intelligence vs AI Image and Video Tools

While many people started out generating humorous images and videos with AI, others quickly realized the power that AI could bring to image and video creation. For instance, you can make an image by entering a basic prompt and generate a video using text or pictures.

To accompany Apple Intelligence, Mac users can take advantage of the Image Playground app. The tool provides simple image creation and can help create emojis. The Photos app also received an update with its intelligent Clean Up tool to remove items from pictures while maintaining integrity.

For third-party tools, apps like Luminar AI, Photoshop AI, Topaz AI, Stable Diffusion, and Runway offer advanced features that go well beyond what Apple can provide. They have sophisticated tools to create and edit professional-grade images and robust features for video enhancements, AI-generated clips, and upscaling.

✅ Where Apple excels: It offers simplicity for basic image creation for a general audience.

❌ Where Apple lacks: It has fewer image creating and editing features and is absent of built-in AI video capabilities which means professional creators still need third-party apps for serious work.

Cost, Privacy, and Hardware Considerations

Before choosing a third-party AI tool for your Mac, be sure to check the pricing and in-app purchase costs, privacy policy, and hardware requirements.

Since Apple Intelligence is built right into macOS and available to use for free with the flip of a switch, that makes it a convenient tool. And because of its ability to run on your local device or using Private Cloud Compute, privacy isn’t a problem.

With third-party apps, you may run into subscription pricing models to get all the features you need as with apps like Jasper, Claude, and Midjourney. As far as privacy, security practices differ by app. Some might collect and process your data while others may only offer secure modes via in-app purchase or an upgraded subscription plan.

Mac hardware is optimized for Apple Intelligence on devices with at least an M1 chip running macOS Sequoia, however; third-party apps may still have specific or additional requirements for use such as external GPUs or cloud support.

Where Each Wins: Quick Comparison Table

For a quick rundown of how Apple Intelligence stacks up to the above-described as well as similar apps, check out this comparison table.

Comparison Table: Apple Intelligence vs. Third-Party AI Apps on Mac (2025)

Category
Apple Intelligence (Built-in) Third-Party AI Tools
Productivity (Notes, Email, Writing)
- Smart writing suggestions (rewrite, summarize, proofread)
- Inline help in Mail, Notes, Safari
- Free & private (on-device/Private Cloud Compute)
- Specialized apps like Otter (transcription), Whisper (speech-to-text), Clean Email (inbox decluttering)
- More customization and automation
- Subscription-based
Assistants & Chat
- Siri with Apple Intelligence: improved context, summaries, proactive help
- Limited compared to AI chatbots
- ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Gemini, Microsoft Copilot
- Advanced research, creativity, coding help
- Multimodal support (text, voice, images)
Image & Creativity
- Simple edits (photo cleanup, emoji generation)
- Limited creative freedom
- Luminar AI, Photoshop AI, Topaz AI, Stable Diffusion, MidJourney
- Professional-grade photo/video editing and AI art
- Much broader features
Video Tools
- No built-in advanced video AI features - Topaz Video AI, Runway, InVideo, Luma AI
- Video enhancement, AI-generated clips, denoising, upscaling
Privacy & Security
- Strong: runs on-device or via Apple’s “Private Cloud Compute”
- Data not sold or used for training
- Varies: some prioritize privacy, others collect usage data
- Cloud-based processing often required
Cost
- Free with macOS (included) - Most require subscriptions (e.g., Claude Pro, Jasper, MidJourney)
- Some free tiers available
Hardware Integration
- Optimized for Apple Silicon (M3, M4 chips)
- Seamless with macOS apps
- Runs well on Macs but may require external GPUs or cloud support for heavy workloads

The Best Combo: Apple + Third-Party AIs

As you already know, a single app, feature, or service can’t do it all. That’s why creating the perfect combo is key to using AI to its full capacity. While you’ll likely come up with your own ideal mixture of AI tools for Mac, here’s an example of how to make the perfect combination:

Apple Intelligence for summaries + Clean Email for inbox cleanup + ChatGPT for research

With Apple Intelligence, you can summarize an email or thread, unread text conversations, audio recordings, web pages, and notifications.

Then, use Clean Email to reduce inbox clutter and organize your inbox with Unsubscriber, smart Cleaning Suggestions, Auto Clean rules, and bulk actions.

Filter All Emails Automatically Using Clean EmailFilter All Emails Automatically Using Clean Email

Finally, give ChatGPT a prompt for details on most any topic, whether for business, education, or personal projects.

Think about what your best AI app for Mac combo will include!

Conclusion

So, what’s the best AI for Mac? Is it Apple Intelligence because of its convenience, privacy, and integrations? Is it a third-party app like Clean Email for efficient mailbox management or Whisper Notes for offline speech-to-text captures? Or is it an AI combo that allows each app to do what it does best in conjunction with other tools?

You decide!

📌 For further reading on this topic, look at which is more effective, Clean Email or Gemini AI in Gmail.


Apple Intelligence vs. Third-Party AI on Mac – FAQs

Can I disable Apple Intelligence on my Mac if I prefer third-party AI tools?

Yes. Apple allows users to opt out of Apple Intelligence features in macOS settings.

Does Apple Intelligence work offline on a Mac?

Many Apple Intelligence tasks (like rewriting text or summarizing notes) run fully on-device, especially on Macs with M3 or newer chips. However, some advanced tasks may rely on Apple’s Private Cloud Compute for processing.

Will older Intel-based Macs get Apple Intelligence?

No. Apple Intelligence is limited to Macs running on Apple Silicon (M1 and newer). Intel Macs will not receive these features, so third-party apps remain the best option.

Which AI app for Mac is best for students?

Students benefit from tools like Otter.ai (lecture transcription), ChatGPT (study help, explanations), and Clean Email (keeping academic inboxes organized, not AI but acts AI-like). Apple Intelligence also helps summarize study notes natively.

Are free AI tools for Mac worth using?

Yes. Free options like ChatGPT’s basic plan, Perplexity free tier, and MacWhisper for transcription provide solid functionality. However, premium versions of AI apps often unlock more reliable and advanced features.

Can I run Stable Diffusion locally on a Mac?

Yes. With tools like DiffusionBee or other macOS GUIs, you can run Stable Diffusion models directly on Macs with Apple Silicon. It requires significant storage and memory but avoids cloud costs.

Is Apple Intelligence safe for sensitive work emails?

Apple emphasizes privacy: most tasks are processed on-device, and cloud requests use Private Cloud Compute with no data storage.

Do AI tools slow down a Mac?

Lightweight AI features like Apple Intelligence run smoothly on Apple Silicon. Heavy apps like video upscalers (Topaz, Runway) can tax system resources. Cloud-based AI apps don’t strain your Mac directly, since processing happens online.

Can I use both Apple Intelligence and third-party AI tools together?

Absolutely. Many users will benefit from combining them — for example, using Apple Intelligence for text rewrites, Clean Email for AI-like inbox decluttering, and ChatGPT for brainstorming.

Will Apple Intelligence eventually replace third-party AI apps?

Unlikely. While Apple offers excellent system-level tools, third-party apps evolve faster and cover more advanced use cases (creative work, coding, research). The best approach is using them side by side.

Do I need an internet connection to use AI apps on a Mac?

Some AI apps (like Apple Intelligence, MacWhisper, Stable Diffusion GUIs) run offline, while others (ChatGPT, Perplexity, MidJourney) require constant internet access.

Can Apple Intelligence help with coding on Mac?

Not directly. Apple Intelligence is focused on writing, organization, and everyday tasks. For coding, third-party tools like Copilot AI or ChatGPT remain much stronger.

Will AI apps drain my MacBook’s battery faster?

Yes, heavy AI workloads like image generation or video upscaling can tax the CPU/GPU and reduce battery life. Lighter AI tasks (summarizing notes, email sorting) have minimal impact.

What’s the difference between browser-based AI tools and Mac-native AI apps?

Browser tools (ChatGPT web, MidJourney on Discord) are easy to access but lack deep OS integration.

Mac-native apps (ChatGPT for Mac, Otter.ai, Luminar AI) offer better offline support, hotkeys, and performance optimization.

Are AI apps for Mac safe to download outside the App Store?

Most AI tools are distributed via developer websites (e.g., Topaz, Luminar) and are safe if downloaded directly. Avoid cracked versions, which may contain malware.

Do AI apps for Mac work with iCloud and Apple ecosystem features?

Apple Intelligence integrates natively with iCloud and system apps. Some third-party apps sync with cloud services, but most don’t tie directly into Apple’s ecosystem.

Can AI organize files and folders on my Mac?

Yes. Apple Intelligence helps with smart search and summaries, while third-party tools like Hazel (automation) or Clean Email (AI-like inbox organization) provide deeper automation.

Will Apple Intelligence eventually integrate with professional apps like Final Cut or Logic Pro?

Apple hasn’t announced this yet, but given its focus on creative users, future versions of macOS may bring AI features into professional workflows.

What are the limitations of Apple Intelligence compared to third-party AI apps?

Apple Intelligence is great for everyday writing, summaries, and privacy. But it lacks advanced capabilities like AI video editing, deep research, or professional photo enhancement.

Should businesses rely on Apple Intelligence or third-party AI tools?

Businesses will likely need third-party apps (for collaboration, transcription, advanced automation). Apple Intelligence is more focused on personal productivity.

Try Clean Email for Free
*****4.4based on 1011 user reviews
Get Started
InboxClean Your Mailbox

Use tools like Cleaning Suggestions and Smart Folders to help you quickly clean out an overloaded inbox

Mute unwanted emailsUnsubscribe

Keep unwanted emails out of your inbox by unsubscribing—even from email lists that don’t have an unsubscribe link

Clean your emailsKeep it Clean

Automate repetitive tasks with Auto Clean rules to archive emails as they become old or to sort them into folders

Background
Use filters to find emails you want to clean.Arrow
Screener FeatureArrow
UnsubscribeArrow
Auto CleanArrow
Sender SettingsArrow